You Gotta Love It!
by Geoff Fuller
(First appeared in the Guide to Literary Agents.)

Madeline DiMaggio: Screenwriter, Writing Teacher, Script Doctor

In the screenwriting workshops that Madeline DiMaggio conducts throughout the United States and Europe, she has found that its the writers who love it most that are ultimately the most successful. She remembers one of her students telling her about a specific turning point in his career.

Somebody asked Kevin how many screenplays he wrote before he sold, DiMaggio told Writers Digest, and he said, Seven.And that person asked, What kept you going? And he said, You know what?I know the moment that I asked myself that question. I was driving on the freeway. I was getting on the on-ramp, and an inner voice asked me, What if I never sell a script? And then I heard the answer.Im going to keep writing anyway, because I love it.

DiMaggios student was Kevin Falls, who is now an Emmy winner as the co-executive producer on the popular and critically acclaimed NBC television show, The West Wing.

Throughout the interview, DiMaggio framed the points she was making as little scenes. No matter what she was trying to explain, she created a scene in which she played all the parts.It was as if her mind automatically translated everything into the form that films require.You see, Ms. DiMaggio loves to write; she has been a story editor and creative consultant for Paramount Studios, but writing is her first love.She enjoys the whole process, from idea through development through execution, and if she didnt love it so, she probably wouldnt have achieved the success that she has had to date.

She began her career working on a lot of cop shows, among them, the 1970s police drama Starsky and HutchFrom there she moved to situation comedies like Bob Newhartand Threes Company.Later, she wrote movie-length screenplays, or long form, as she called it, which are not necessarily more difficult. Its just that they require different talents.

Most recently, she finished a special for Showtime, Murder With Privilege, and the first draft of a movie script for Commotion Films entitled Catherine Called Birdy, both of which she co-wrote with Pamela Wallace, a frequent collaborator and the author of Witness, a 1985 movie that starred Harrison Ford and garnered an Academy Award for Wallace.DiMaggio characterized Catherine Called Birdyas Cluelessmeets Shakespeare in Love.Were on a good roll with that one.Its a fun script.It was like a dream project from the get-go.

Q:Is there a particular strength to your work?Something you do especially well?

MD:I come from an acting background, and I have an ear for dialogue, and pacing and tempo.I highly recommend that writers take an acting class.Some writers are tone deaf, and either you have a good sense or not. It can be taught, but I think with actors it becomes automatic.After all the years of acting that I put in, Im in tune with the flow and the pacing and the tempo and the fun of dialogue. Its just my favorite thing.

Q:I understand that a lot of actors will tone up the dialogue, give it more impact.

MD:Yes, that happens a lot.It depends on the power of the actor, but when you look at Aaron Sorkins work on West Wing, I hear the actors dont even stray from an ahh in the script.But Sorkins dialogue is utterly brilliant. It really depends on who the writer is, who the actors are, and what the medium is. And the personality of the director.

Q: How did you get into script doctoring?

MD:I got into script doctoring through teaching.I was reading writers material and I go down to Hollywood, I pitch to Hollywood, I write for Hollywood, and I knew the material wasnt ready.It needed that professional edge.

What I try to provide for writers who are trying to get into the marketplace is the benefit of all my years of rejection.I try to show them how to get into the story later, give the story more edge, have characters we root forare riveted byand make the story as visual as possible.How to give it all that polish that says professional.

Ill tell you, there are a lot of good script doctors out there, and I highly recommend that everybody get the critique before they go out because writers are just too close to their material.Youve only got one shot.Once a particular company rejects you, you dont have another shot with that company. You want to do the best possible presentation you can do.

Q:What are the most common weaknesses you see in screenplays?

MD:The biggest fatal flaw is structure. Also, the characters need to drive the story forward rather than the plot.Many, many, many times, Ill read a screenplay thats plot-driven and the characters are stuck in there like automatons to take the story from point A to B to C.The next move should be created by the characters and not by the plot.

Give a character a compelling need, and then its the writers job to create obstacles to that need, and its those obstacles that create conflict, that create all the action.We are who we are by what we dontget, not what we get. Were made by what we dont get.Character-Need-Obstacle-Action.All good stories are based in conflict.And thats another fatal flaw in screenplays: not enough conflict.The stakes are not high enough.You hear that in Hollywood all the time.

Q:Do you believe, as Jeffrey Katzenberg and others have maintained, that the idea is king?

MD:Yes.You can say, well, doesnt that conflict with the fact that you have to write from your passion, you have to write from your heart?But yes, story is king.Concept is crucial.However, it has to be executed well, and a lot of writers dont have a bent for that high-commercial edge.I mean, if you are Shane Black, and your passion is an action type of Lethal Weapon movie, then you are a very lucky individual.
However, what if you are not that kind of writer?When you fabricate that, it shows.To put yourself into a pigeon-hole and attempt to write for the sale, it shows.So I tell writers to be very careful.Its a two-edged sword.Yes, you need an idea that is extremely marketable and strong, but, yes, you also have to have something thats well written, honest.Before you commit to writing, make sure you love your idea.Make sure it makes the hairs on your arm stand up, because youre going to be living with it for a very long time.It takes a long time to write a screenplay, it takes a long time to rewrite it, and it takes a long time to market it.You better love what youre doing, because its a commitment.

Q:Do you think theres a difference between the way males and females approach story and idea in a script?

MD:Thats an excellent question, and I think there is.Writers need to watch that.They talk about ageism in Hollywood, they talk about genderism, they talk about all those things that to some extent exist, but what often happens is that you can see those things in a script.You can read a writers age in a script and you can read the gender, and thats not good.Because thats the writer taking a point of view.So you want to be careful of that.I think women can write action, and I think men can go into the heart of a woman.They can go into a womans soul.Unmarried Woman, a very old film, is a brilliant insight into being a female, and it was written by a man.But try to detach yourself from who you are and just write a good story, so that its not identifiable.Hollywood tries to pigeonhole you, and you can avoid that to some degree if you keep your own point of view out of the story.

Q:What, exactly, is a coverage?

MD:Its unavoidable and its a roulette table.When you turn in a screenplay, it does not get to the producer, it does not get to the story editoralmost always it goes to the reader.And the reader writes coverage on the material.The reader might be somebodys kid whos home for summer vacation or the reader can be a member of the Writers Guild whos been doing it for 25 years.Its the luck of the draw.Unless you get with some very small production company or you get read by somebody you can get to directly, it always happens through coverage.
The reader essentially writes a synopsis of what the story is about, who the characters are, whats wrong with the story, if it works, if it doesnt, if the writer is recommended for other projects.That way someone can look at the coverage and decide if the screenplay should be passed on to someone up the ladder.And its not only Is it well written? but whether the story fits the companys agenda.

Q:Discuss the difference between a treatment and a full screenplay.

MD:A treatment is in prose, and its basically a synopsis of the storyline done in present tense.Just like all movies are made in present tense.You dont put in the treatment what couldnt be shown on the screen.I dont have the luxury of going into interior monologue like I do in a book.Essentially, its a synopsis of the storyline of the movie.

Q:Ive heard it recommended that an aspiring screenwriter work on a treatment before writing a full screenplay.

MD:I absolutely agree with that, but the treatment is for the writer, its not to market.Its to get the story down with a strong beginning, middle, and end.Its to create a structure that works, and from that, the writer can create the screenplay.Everything in the screenplay should matter.A treatment should be like an artists work table where you can cut and paste and make sure the story works before you commit to a first draft.
In fact, when Pam [Wallace] and I work together, we start with one page.Then we expand it to 3 or 4 pages.Then expand it to maybe 10 pages.Until we absolutely agree on storyline, we know where were going, we deal with issues before its writtenwhat we want to accomplish, what we want to say, the tone, the stakesthen we go to first draft.

Q:What about pitches?Does every writer need to frame their story in 2 or 3 sentences?

MD:I highly recommend that all writers do that.It doesnt necessarily mean that they market it like that, but it clarifies things for the writer.In my classes, I ask writers, What movie is it most like?Not because theyre copying the film or plagiarizing it, but because it roots the writer in knowing tone.It roots the writer in knowing what they want to accomplish.I tell writers, If you cant define it, you cant write it.I ask writers to define their story in 4 or 5 lines.

Q:What kinds of objections to that do you hear to that?

MD:Objections?

Q:Like, My storys much too complex to. . .

MD:Ah!You know, I was teaching an advanced screenwriting course in Hawaiiand I dont believe theres such a thing as an advanced screenwriter, I mean, a writer can be experienced, but every story has a new set of challengesbut these people were considered advanced because they were all in the process of writing screenplays.So I said to them, Your first assignment is to go home and come back tomorrow with 3 lines of what your story is about.Out of about 12 writers, 6 could do it.If you cant define the main line of action in your story, youve got a problem.
So heres a story about a lost alien who gets befriended by boys who help him find his way back home.Well, thats ET.Theres a lot thats not in therethe government finding him, dying on the operating table, Eliot bringing him home. . . Fine, fine, but thats not the kernel of what the story is about.Thats not what it hinges on.And thats what writers should be able to define.

Q:And once the writer defines that, the writer can pitch it?

MD:Writers are terrified of pitching.Absolutely terrified.So I try to tell writers not to worry about pitching because they wont be doing it.I mean, the bottom line is that until you can write a screenplay and can prove that you can write, you wont be invited in by companies who want to hear your idea.The most important marketing tool you will ever have is your screenplay.Thats number one.The most important thing a writer can do is write a good screenplay.

Q:Thank you, Ms. DiMaggio, for allowing us your time here.A couple of last things:What do you see as the hottest trends in Hollywood today?

MD:Dont ever go by trends.By the time you write and market, the trend has passed.It takes too long to write the stories, too long to market them.Never try to create on a trend.People may say, The teen market is flooded or The public is tired of Vietnam stories, but there will always be a teen market, there will always be another Vietnam story.The point is that if you try to create on a trend, you will always be behind the wave.You want to get out front, and so that means that you should always save everything you do, because the trend will come back around.
Im marketing something now thats 12 years old.The screenplay that Pam [Wallace] and I did recently was from a book that the producer couldnt set up for 4 years.These things are not overnight!Whatever you get rejected on, keep it in your portfolio, because you never know when you can pull it up, when you can rewrite it, when itll be timely.None of its a waste.

Q:You Can Write a Movie, Pamela Wallace said that the two most important things are to believe in yourself and to write from the heart.Youve mentioned a lot of useful things today, a lot of good advice, but what would be your two primary pieces of advice?

MD:Thats a very good question.I definitely agree with writing from your heart because I think a writer must feel passionately about what they write about.That comes across in the read.I think many times writers try to be too commercial and they arent writing from the truth of who they are.The most important thing that happens in a script is its emotional honesty.
I was with a very well known agent once and he said he read a screenplay that he knew wouldnt be commercial, but it was so emotionally honest, he took on that writer as a client because he could feel it in the readthat passion, that truth.And the love of what youre doing is absolutely key, because Ill tell you what, Ive been in workshops with incredible writers and good writers, and its not the incredible writers who necessarily make it.Its not even all the time the good writers.Its the writers that love it the most and hang in there the longest.Those are the ones who make it.

Sidebar

DiMaggio Highly Recommends. . .

  • Never turn in a treatment unless its asked for, because it encourages readers not to read.
  • Take an acting class.Thats why so many actors are good writers, because they have a good ear.
  • Get a critique before you go out because youre just too close to your material.
  • Enter as many contests as you can.You get read by professionals, and you get noticed.The word gets out on the grapevine.
Email Madeline@cre8ascript.com